Publication / AI & finance

Generative AI and the Evolution of Mortgage Underwriting: Measuring and Mitigating Racial Disparities

With McKay Price, Luke Stein, and Ke Yang

The Journal of Real Estate Finance and Economics (2026) Journal article

Auditing racial disparities in LLM mortgage underwriting, and testing ways to reduce them.

Read PDF Read with AI
Abstract

Mortgage underwriting is entering a new phase of technological change as general-purpose generative AI tools begin to appear in mortgage origination workflows. We develop an audit framework to evaluate how large language models process mortgage applications. Using real HMDA applications, we experimentally manipulate borrower race, race proxies, and credit quality, and prompt leading commercial LLMs to make approval and pricing recommendations. LLMs recommend more denials and higher interest rates for Black applicants than otherwise identical white applicants, with disparities largest for riskier loans and persisting when race is signaled through names or locations. A simple instruction to avoid bias substantially reduces disparities when race is explicit, partially reduces the name-based pricing gap, and does little against the geographic pricing gap. In matched HMDA–Freddie Mac data, race-blind LLM recommendations correlate with actual lender pricing and subsequent delinquency, though the delinquency association operates largely through observed credit scores. The results show how AI auditing can inform mortgage underwriting governance before general-purpose models become more deeply embedded in origination workflows.

Figures
Links

Media & discussion

Awards & recognition

  • Best Paper Award at the 2024 New Zealand Finance Meeting
  • ARES 2025 Manuscript Prize for Real Estate Finance ($1,000)
  • ARES 2025 Innovative Thinking “Thinking Out of the Box” Prize ($1,000)

Notes

Formerly titled “Measuring and Mitigating Racial Disparities in LLMs: Evidence from a Mortgage Underwriting Experiment”

Paper XML