Publication / Technology diffusion
What’s your identification strategy? Innovation in corporate finance research
Management Science (2017) 63(8): 2529-2548 Journal article
How identification strategies spread through corporate finance research.
Abstract
We study the diffusion of techniques designed to identify causal relationships in corporate finance research. We estimate the diffusion started in the mid-nineties, lags twenty years compared to economics, and is now used in the majority of corporate finance articles. Consistent with recent theories of technology diffusion, the adoption varies across researchers based on individuals’ expected net benefits of adoption. Younger scholars, holders of PhDs in economics, and those working at top institutions adopt faster. Adoption is accelerated through networks of colleagues and alumni and is also facilitated by straddlers who cross-over from economics to finance. Our findings highlight new forces that explain the diffusion of innovation and shape the norms of academic research.
Figures

Causal identification becomes mainstream in corporate finance

Identification papers develop a citation advantage in corporate finance

Identification papers also command a citation premium in economics

Editors increasingly adopt the methods reshaping corporate finance

Diagnostic checks lag the adoption of instrumental variables

Difference-in-differences spreads faster than its diagnostic tests